Print Composite Schedule Note: Games in Dark Blue Indicate Conference Contests; Bold Indicates Victor
| Date | Away | Score | Home | Score | |||
| Oct. 17 | Findlay | 61 | Ashland | 139 | Results | ||
| Oct. 18 | Indianapolis | 3rd/4 308 | Indiana Intercollegiates | Results | |||
| Hillsdale | 140.5 | Ashland | 139.5 | Results | |||
| St. Cloud (Minn.) | 237 | Northern Michigan | 61 | Results | |||
| Northern Michigan | 80 | Minnesota-Moorhead | 218 | Results | |||
| Hillsdale | 240 | Urbana | 8 | ||||
| Urbana | 8 | Ashland | 222 | ||||
| Oct. 24 | Illinois Institute of Technology | NTS | Lewis | NTS | Results | Recap | ||
| Robert Morris (Ill.) | NTS | Lewis | NTS | Results | Recap | |||
| Oct. 25 | Alma (Mich.) | 45 | Findlay | 64 | Results | Recap | ||
| Urbana (Ohio) | 4 | Findlay | 92 | Results | Recap | |||
| Lewis | 58 | Grand Valley State | 146 | Results | Recap | |||
| Wayne State | 74 | Oakland (Mich.) | 226 | Results | Recap | |||
| Hillsdale | 92 | Grand Valley State | 134 | Results | Recap | |||
| Lewis | 80 | Hillsdale | 141 | Results | Recap | |||
| Wayne State | 100 | Cincinnati | 200 | Results | Recap | |||
| Oct. 31 | Calvin (Mich.) | 118.5 | Grand Valley State | 170.5 | Results | Recap | ||
| Nov. 1 | Ashland | 62 | Wayne State | 161 | Results | ||
| Ashland | 87 | Indianapolis | 135 | Results | |||
| Wayne State | 136.5 | Indianapolis | 94.5 | Results | |||
| Truman (Mo.) | 146 | Indianapolis | 77 | Results | |||
| Truman (Mo.) | 110 | Wayne State | 113 | Results | |||
| Truman (Mo.) | 155 | Ashland | 50 | Results | |||
| Findlay | 56 | Wheeling Jesuit (W.Va.) | 38 | Results | Recap | |||
| Findlay | 19 | Indiana (Pa.) | 75 | Results | Recap | |||
| Lewis | 2nd/4 Teams 451 | Kiefer Fall Invite (Wis.) | Results | Recap | ||||
| Northern Michigan | 3rd/4 423 | Keifer Fall Invite (Wis.) | Results | ||||
| Nov. 7 | Findlay | 44 | Albion (Mich.) | 67 | Results | Recap | ||
| Findlay | 42 | Hillsdale | 69 | Results | Recap | |||
| Albion (Mich.) | 42 | Hillsdale | 70 | Results | Recap | |||
| Nov. 8 | Grand Valley State | 175.5 | Ashland | 115.5 | Results | Recap | ||
| UW-Oshkosh | 133 | Northern Michigan | 98 | Results | Recap | |||
| Nov. 14 | Michigan State | 169 | Grand Valley State | 72 | Results | Recap | ||
| Nov. 15 | Indianapolis | 155 | Ashland | 125 | Results | ||
| Calvin (Mich.) | 71 | Wayne State | 170 | Results | Recap | |||
| Denison (Ohio) | 118.50 | Wayne State | 122.50 | Results | Recap | |||
| Olivet (Mich.) | 86 | Hillsdale | 152 | Results | |||
| Ohio Northern | 70 | Hillsdale | 164 | Results | |||
| Nov. 16 | Lewis | NTS | USA Swimming/Toyota Grand Prix | Results | |||
| Nov. 22 | Findlay | 3rd/3 190 | Doug Coers Invitational | Results | Recap | |||
| Grand Valley State | 2nd/3 594 | Doug Coers Invitational | Results | Recap | ||||
| Chicago (Ill.) | 161 | Lewis | 98 | Results | Recap | |||
| Hillsdale | 169 | Northern Michigan | 118 | Results | Recap | |||
| Nov. 23 | Ashland | 4th/5 | Western Kentucky Invitational | Recap | |||
| Dec. 6 | Grand Valley State | 1st/7 951 | Wheaton College Invite | Results | Recap | |||
| Findlay | 9th/10 81 | Eastern Michigan Invitational | Results | Recap | ||||
| Wayne State | 4th/10 578 | Eastern Michigan Invitational | Results | Recap | ||||
| Indianapolis | 4th/7 409 | House of Champions Invite (IUPUI) | Results | Recap | ||||
| Hillsdale | 3rd/8 883 | TYR Invitational | Results | Recap | ||||
| Northern Michigan | 7th/10 119 | Eastern Michigan Invitational | Results | Recap | ||||
| Findlay | 8th/9 30 | Grove City Invitational | Results | Recap | ||||
| Dec. 17 | Ashland | 196 | Lewis | 130 | Results | Recap | ||
| Jan. 9 | Wayne State | 121 | Grand Valley State | 122 | Results | Recap | ||
| Truman (Mo.) | 157 | Lewis | 46 | Results | Recap | |||
| Jan. 10 | Truman (Mo.) | 36 | Lewis | 167 | Results | Recap | ||
| Ashland | 198 | Catawaba (N.C.) | 60 | Results | |||
| Ashland | 127 | Washington & Lee (Va.) | 135 | Results | |||
| Ashland | 109 | Wingate (N.C.) | 153 | Results | |||
| Butler (Ind.) | NTS | Indianapolis | NTS | Results | Recap | |||
| IUPUI | NTS | Indianapolis | NTS | Results | Recap | |||
| Jan. 16 | Grand Valley State | 188 | Findlay | 89 | Results | Recap | ||
| Kenyon (Ohio) | 148 | Ashland | 57 | Results | Recap | |||
| St. Marys (Ind.) | 93 | Indianapolis | 145 | Results | Recap | |||
| Jan. 17 | Wayne State | 171 | Lewis | 52 | Results | Recap | ||
| Indiana (Pa.) | 87 | Ashland | 118 | Results | Recap | |||
| Ohio Wesleyan | 117 | Findlay | 119 | Results | Recap | |||
| Hillsdale | 84.5 | Wayne State | 150.5 | Results | Recap | |||
| Hillsdale | 137 | Lewis | 85 | Results | Recap | |||
| Jan. 23 | Hope (Mich.) | 77.5 | Grand Valley State | 156.5 | Results | Recap | ||
| Edinboro (Pa.) | 71 | Ashland | 134 | Results | |||
| Wayne State | 82 | Eastern Michigan | 155 | Results | Recap | |||
| Jan. 24 | Clarion (Pa.) | 162 | Ashland | 123 | Results | ||
| Indianapolis | 118 | Grand Valley State | 174 | Results | Recap | |||
| St. Marys (Ind.) | 64 | Hillsdale | 167 | Results | Recap | |||
| Jan. 25 | Findlay | 102 | Wilmington College | 100 | Results | Recap | ||
| Jan. 31 | Indianapolis | 112 | Lewis | 92 | Results | Recap | ||
| Grand Valley State | 170 | Northern Michigan | 69 | Results | Recap | |||
| Ashland | Wayne State Diving Invitational | Results | |||||
| Wayne State | Wayne State Diving Invitational | Results | |||||
| Hillsdale | Wayne State Diving Invitational | Results | |||||
| Feb. 14 | 2009 GLIAC Championship Results and Final Team Scores | Results | |||||
| 1st Place Grand Valley State University | 897 | ||||||
| 2nd Place Wayne State University | 869 | ||||||
| 3rd Place University of Indianapolis | 433 | ||||||
| 4th Place Ashland University | 392.5 | ||||||
| 5th Place Hillsdale College | 372 | ||||||
| 6th Place Lewis University | 232 | ||||||
| 7th Place University of Findlay | 214 | ||||||
| 8th Place Northern Michigan University | 153.5 | ||||||
| Feb. 20 | Findlay | 9th/9 17 | Kenyon (Ohio) | Results | |||
| Mar. 14 | NCAA DII National Championships | Final Results | Results | ||||
| Drury | 1st/33 618.5 | ||||||
| Wayne State | 2nd/33 453.5 | ||||||
| Grand Valley State | 9th/33 153.5 | ||||||
| Indianapolis | 11th/33 137 | ||||||
| Northern Michigan | 27th/33 9 | ||||||
| Findlay | 31st/33 4 | ||||||
